[From the next room.]

On what?

[He emerges a moment later with a small object wrapped in what looks like a scrap of Christmasy-colored fabric and tied up with string.]

I couldn't find any paper either, but I did find a random bolt of tacky, red and green cloth. Which is actually pretty good for this since it's a little fragile.

[He hands Sam her gift, and when she unwraps it she'll find a beautiful, rainbow-colored suncatcher.]